I actually would rate this book a 3.5, but I was feeling generous, so I rounded up. It is a neat little book, good for those who like fantasy, paranormal romance,etc., but it has its flaws, the biggest (for me) being that the ending felt very abrupt, and some things were just too obvious. But it is YA, so maybe to a 14 yr old, they wouldnt be so obvious. Nothing to write home about, but a nice light read nonetheless.